Task: Crtically consider ideas discussed from the above texts and the lecture presentations.
Zoffany, Johann. Portrait of Dido Elizabeth Belle Lindsay and Her Cousin Lady Elizabeth Murray. 1778. Oil on Canvas. Kenwood House, Scotland.
Video: Smarthistory Art historical analysis (painting), using Édouard Manet, A Bar at the Folies-Bergère, 1882.
Idea: Approaching an artwork critically, dissecting its elements, and having an in depth analysis. Looking at its subject matter, considering its narrative, possible meanings, socio-political norms of the times, etc.
Artwork: Portrait of Dido Elizabeth Belle and her cousin, Elizabeth Murray.
Beth Harris and Steven Zucker talk about in their video, critically analyzing a painting and dissecting its possible meanings, narrative, symbolisms, viewpoints and artistic technicalities with “A Bar at the Folies-Bergere” by Edouard Manet. This allows the viewer to critically think about other visual texts similarly, such as the portrait of Dido Elizabeth Belle with her cousin, Elizabeth Murray.
The portrait, unusual for its time, portrays a black woman and a white woman as equals, or near equals. Paintings of the time had their white subjects (the English nobility) dominant whilst the black subject (a servant or slave) looking up at the white “protagonist”. Murray is portrayed as a scholarly, demure English lady with her rigid pose and a book in hand, a huge contrast to her black cousin. Dido is portrayed in the exact opposite; she is painted with great vivacity and holding a bowl of fruit as if she was going to serve others. Both women wear outfits reflecting their social status but their positioning and actions within the painting allude to a hint of their racial differences.
Resources:
Art: Smarthistory. art, history, conversation. Édouard Manet, A Bar at the Folies-Bergère, 1882